How Poor Carrier Management Can Kill Your Margins (And What to Do About It)

How Poor Carrier Management Can Kill Your Margins (And What to Do About It)

Most freight brokers think their biggest cost concern is shippers demanding lower rates—but that’s only part of the equation. What many don’t realize is that poor carrier management is silently eating away at their margins every day.

Every late pickup, every unexpected rate spike, and every unreliable carrier choice adds up. Over time, these small inefficiencies drain tens of thousands of dollars from your bottom line.

Let’s break down exactly how carrier mismanagement kills profits—and what you can do to stop it.

1. Overpaying for Freight Due to Poor Rate Negotiations

Many brokerages lack the time or expertise to consistently negotiate competitive rates with carriers. Instead of securing the best possible rates, they settle for whatever’s available last minute—leading to higher costs and tighter margins.

Example: If you’re routinely paying $150-$200 extra per load because you’re booking carriers in a rush, that quickly turns into $5,000+ in lost profits every month.

What You Can Do:

• Start benchmarking your freight rates. Instead of accepting the first quote, compare against current market rates using tools like DAT or Truckstop.
• Develop long-term carrier partnerships. Instead of relying on the spot market, lock in dedicated rates with carriers who handle your lanes consistently.
• Time your bookings better. Avoid last-minute load tenders when rates are highest—plan ahead and secure capacity early.
• Consider hiring a team of experienced negotiators who know how to lock in lower rates without sacrificing quality.‍‍

‍2. Load Failures and Service Disruptions = Lost Revenue

A carrier cancels last minute. Another one arrives late and misses the shipper’s dock hours. A broker scrambles to find coverage and pays extra to get the load moved.

This isn’t just a bad day—it’s a pattern that drains revenue. Brokerages without a reliable carrier network deal with:

• More emergency coverage costs
• Missed loads that damage shipper relationships
• Operational delays that create chaos for the entire team

Example: A brokerage that misses just five loads per month due to carrier no-shows could be losing $10,000+ annually in penalties, rush fees, and lost contracts.

What You Can Do:

• Track carrier performance. Maintain a record of on-time pickups, transit reliability, and communication history to eliminate underperforming carriers.
• Diversify your carrier network. Relying too much on a small pool of carriers increases your risk of failures—broaden your network for redundancy.
• Use contract commitments. Establish SLAs (Service Level Agreements) with key carriers to ensure accountability and performance guarantees.
• Work with a team that has a vetted carrier network. Brokers who work with experienced carrier sales professionals get faster, more reliable coverage.

3. Compliance Violations That Lead to Expensive Penalties

Carriers operating with expired insurance, missing FMCSA compliance, or a history of violations put your brokerage at a huge financial and legal risk. If your team isn’t actively monitoring carrier compliance, you could end up booking non-compliant carriers—which can result in FMCSA penalties, legal liability, and even lost contracts with shippers.

Example: A brokerage that unknowingly books a carrier with expired insurance could face thousands in liability claims if an accident occurs.

What You Can Do:

• Automate compliance checks. Use tools like RMIS, Carrier411, or SaferWatch to continuously monitor insurance, safety scores, and violations.
• Require updated COIs (Certificates of Insurance). Before assigning any load, make sure your carriers submit a valid, up-to-date COI.
• Create a blacklist. Track carriers with past violations and ensure they don’t get rebooked.
• Consider hiring a dedicated compliance team that keeps bad carriers out of your network.

4. Wasting Time on Carrier Management Instead of Growing Your Business

Most brokerages spend too much time handling carrier sales when they should be focused on growing their shipper relationships. 

Example: If your team spends 30% of their workday on carrier issues, that’s dozens of potential shipper deals left on the table every month.

What You Can Do:

• Delegate non-revenue tasks. Carrier onboarding, compliance checks, and load tracking can be handled by an operations assistant or outsourced team.
• Prioritize high-value tasks. Your team should be spending most of their time building relationships with shippers and growing revenue, not firefighting carrier issues.

5. Scaling Your Brokerage Without Losing Control

As your brokerage grows, so do your carrier needs. But if your current team is already struggling to book loads, negotiate rates, and ensure compliance, scaling becomes nearly impossible.

If you can’t handle increased load volume efficiently, shippers will take their business elsewhere.

A brokerage that tries to double its monthly shipments without a scalable carrier sales team risks service breakdowns, frustrated shippers, and lost revenue opportunities.

What You Can Do:
✔ Automate carrier matching. Use a TMS with AI-driven load matching to assign loads faster and reduce manual work.
✔ Build a tiered carrier network. Prioritize high-performing carriers for core lanes while maintaining a secondary pool for backup capacity.
✔ Consider outsourcing carrier sales. Hiring an in-house team and training that team is often not cost-effective. Instead of that consider working with experienced professionals can ensure you scale without operational stress.

Poor Carrier Management Is a Profit Killer—But You Can Fix It

If your brokerage is struggling with shrinking margins, unreliable carriers, or inefficient carrier sales, it’s time to rethink your strategy. Every bad carrier decision costs money. Delays, overpaying on rates, compliance mistakes—they all add up.

Stop wasting time and money figuring it out on your own!  Superior offers a tried-and-tested approach that bypasses costly mistakes and fast-tracks your brokerage to higher profits and smoother operations. Our dedicated carrier sales experts have already tackled the challenges—so you don’t have to. 

Partner with Superior and:

• Save thousands per month by improving rate negotiations
• Eliminate load failures with a vetted, reliable carrier network
• Eliminate compliance risks before they cost you money
• Free up time to focus on customer acquisition and business growth 

 Let’s talk. Schedule a Free Consultation Today

‍